MENU
Grey marble (probably bardiglio), mounted on a yellow Siena and white marble base; tusks missing
55 cm high
PROVENANCE
Acquired by Étienne Denis (1889–1962) in the 1920s;
by descent to his son Alphonse Denis (1923–2016);
Private collection, Toulon;
Artcurial, Paris, 22 November 2023, lot 172 (as ‘Ecole probablement romaine vers 1800’);
where acquired.
THE ELEPHANT: A REDISCOVERED MASTERPIECE BY GAETANO MONTI
Gaetano Monti’s marble Elephant is a work of exceptional rarity and significance. Its rediscovery restores to view not only a sculptor whose œuvre has long remained marginal despite its quality and ambition, but also a singular living animal whose documented journey from India across Europe contributed to shaping Enlightenment perceptions of the exotic beast.
Executed in grey marble and mounted on a Siena and white marble base, the sculpture presents a young Asian male elephant studied from life with remarkable anatomical precision. The decisive confirmation of authorship came with the identification of a plaster reduction in the Museo Giovanni Cappellini, Bologna, bearing the inscription “GAET. MONTI DI MILANO FECE DAL NATURALE” and a quotation from Pliny describing the elephant as the animal closest to humankind in sensibility. Despite the smaller scale of the plaster, the undeniable similarities with the marble establish the latter as one of Monti’s major works.
Trained in Milan in close dialogue with Andrea Appiani, Monti moved to Rome in around 1780, entering the cultural orbit of the Museo Pio-Clementino, where the Sala degli Animali was taking shape. The typological affinities between this elephant and contemporary animal sculptures produced for that environment, together with Monti’s sustained interest in comparative anatomy, suggest a date in the 1780s. Within this context, Monti emerges as a pioneering figure in Western art. The Elephant stands as one of the earliest examples of animal sculpture conceived through direct observation — anticipating the later tradition of the animalier.
THE JOURNEY OF THE ELEPHANT: CONTEXT FOR AN ENCOUNTER
Elephants were exceptionally rare in 18th century Italy. The only securely documented case prior to the present reconstruction is the elephant kept by Carlo di Borbone, later Charles III of Spain, which resided in the royal menagerie in Caserta between 1742 and 1756, having been presented to the Bourbon court as a diplomatic gift from the Ottoman sultan. Within this context, the animal studied by Monti acquires particular historical significance, as it can now be securely identified. It arrived in Paris from India on 27 December 1770 under the guidance of Pierre-Toussaint Le Gagneur and Antoine Trevisany, before travelling through France, Switzerland and Germany and entering Italy in 1774. Although its journey was comparable in scale and cultural resonance to that of the famous rhinoceros Clara, its history was, for reasons that remain unclear, almost entirely forgotten. Only through the reconstruction of dispersed documentary evidence can its itinerary now be retraced for the first time.
The Italian phase is particularly well documented. The elephant reached Venice during the Carnival of 1774, where its exhibition was immortalised by Pietro Longhi in a celebrated series of paintings that capture both the marvel of the animal and the social ritual of its display. From Venice it proceeded to Milan, where in May 1774 it was shown in the bruolo of Santo Stefano; then to Turin, Parma, Modena and Bologna; to Florence and Siena in early 1775; to Rome in June 1775; and finally to the Kingdom of Naples, where it entered the royal menagerie at Caserta the same year.
Far from being regarded merely as an exotic spectacle, the animal was described in terms that foregrounded its intelligence, memory and capacity for obedience, qualities increasingly interpreted as evidence of a complex inner life. These responses must be read in the context of the rise of natural history and, above all, the work of Georges-Louis Leclerc, comte de Buffon. In his volumes of his Histoire naturelle devoted to Quadrupèdes (1764), Buffon accorded the elephant a privileged position among mammals. Significantly, he had the opportunity to study this very elephant from life in Paris in 1770–71, incorporating his observations into the Suppléments published in 1776.
It was in Milan, in 1774, that Monti almost certainly studied the animal from life. A drawing of an elephant by his close friend and colleague Andrea Appiani, now preserved in the Brera collections, strongly suggests that both artists had the opportunity to observe and study the same animal firsthand during its documented Milanese stay.
The sculpture thus stands as the enduring trace of a documented encounter between artist and animal, at the intersection of Enlightenment empirical study, public spectacle and the emerging modern tradition of animal sculpture.
.jpeg)
.jpeg)
Grey marble (probably bardiglio), mounted on a yellow Siena and white marble base; tusks missing
55 cm high
PROVENANCE
Acquired by Étienne Denis (1889–1962) in the 1920s;
by descent to his son Alphonse Denis (1923–2016);
Private collection, Toulon;
Artcurial, Paris, 22 November 2023, lot 172 (as ‘Ecole probablement romaine vers 1800’);
where acquired.
THE ELEPHANT: A REDISCOVERED MASTERPIECE BY GAETANO MONTI
Gaetano Monti’s marble Elephant is a work of exceptional rarity and significance. Its rediscovery restores to view not only a sculptor whose œuvre has long remained marginal despite its quality and ambition, but also a singular living animal whose documented journey from India across Europe contributed to shaping Enlightenment perceptions of the exotic beast.
Executed in grey marble and mounted on a Siena and white marble base, the sculpture presents a young Asian male elephant studied from life with remarkable anatomical precision. The decisive confirmation of authorship came with the identification of a plaster reduction in the Museo Giovanni Cappellini, Bologna, bearing the inscription “GAET. MONTI DI MILANO FECE DAL NATURALE” and a quotation from Pliny describing the elephant as the animal closest to humankind in sensibility. Despite the smaller scale of the plaster, the undeniable similarities with the marble establish the latter as one of Monti’s major works.
Trained in Milan in close dialogue with Andrea Appiani, Monti moved to Rome in around 1780, entering the cultural orbit of the Museo Pio-Clementino, where the Sala degli Animali was taking shape. The typological affinities between this elephant and contemporary animal sculptures produced for that environment, together with Monti’s sustained interest in comparative anatomy, suggest a date in the 1780s. Within this context, Monti emerges as a pioneering figure in Western art. The Elephant stands as one of the earliest examples of animal sculpture conceived through direct observation — anticipating the later tradition of the animalier.
THE JOURNEY OF THE ELEPHANT: CONTEXT FOR AN ENCOUNTER
Elephants were exceptionally rare in 18th century Italy. The only securely documented case prior to the present reconstruction is the elephant kept by Carlo di Borbone, later Charles III of Spain, which resided in the royal menagerie in Caserta between 1742 and 1756, having been presented to the Bourbon court as a diplomatic gift from the Ottoman sultan. Within this context, the animal studied by Monti acquires particular historical significance, as it can now be securely identified. It arrived in Paris from India on 27 December 1770 under the guidance of Pierre-Toussaint Le Gagneur and Antoine Trevisany, before travelling through France, Switzerland and Germany and entering Italy in 1774. Although its journey was comparable in scale and cultural resonance to that of the famous rhinoceros Clara, its history was, for reasons that remain unclear, almost entirely forgotten. Only through the reconstruction of dispersed documentary evidence can its itinerary now be retraced for the first time.
The Italian phase is particularly well documented. The elephant reached Venice during the Carnival of 1774, where its exhibition was immortalised by Pietro Longhi in a celebrated series of paintings that capture both the marvel of the animal and the social ritual of its display. From Venice it proceeded to Milan, where in May 1774 it was shown in the bruolo of Santo Stefano; then to Turin, Parma, Modena and Bologna; to Florence and Siena in early 1775; to Rome in June 1775; and finally to the Kingdom of Naples, where it entered the royal menagerie at Caserta the same year.
Far from being regarded merely as an exotic spectacle, the animal was described in terms that foregrounded its intelligence, memory and capacity for obedience, qualities increasingly interpreted as evidence of a complex inner life. These responses must be read in the context of the rise of natural history and, above all, the work of Georges-Louis Leclerc, comte de Buffon. In his volumes of his Histoire naturelle devoted to Quadrupèdes (1764), Buffon accorded the elephant a privileged position among mammals. Significantly, he had the opportunity to study this very elephant from life in Paris in 1770–71, incorporating his observations into the Suppléments published in 1776.
It was in Milan, in 1774, that Monti almost certainly studied the animal from life. A drawing of an elephant by his close friend and colleague Andrea Appiani, now preserved in the Brera collections, strongly suggests that both artists had the opportunity to observe and study the same animal firsthand during its documented Milanese stay.
The sculpture thus stands as the enduring trace of a documented encounter between artist and animal, at the intersection of Enlightenment empirical study, public spectacle and the emerging modern tradition of animal sculpture.